Skip to entries
Bonebed Reference shelf for prehistoric life
Clade

Dinosauria 17

Dinosaurs proper, including the birds that survived them.

  • Theropoda 9 Bipedal, mostly carnivorous, hollow-boned.
  • Sauropodomorpha 3 Long-necked, small-headed, graviportal.
  • Ornithischia 5 Bird-hipped plant eaters: plated, armoured, horned, beaked.

Reptiles (non-dinosaur) 4

Animals routinely filed next to dinosaurs and just as routinely mislabelled as one.

  • Pterosauria 1 Flying archosaurs with a membrane wing on one finger.
  • Mosasauridae 1 Open-ocean squamates with a flipper-paddled tail.
  • Plesiosauria 1 Four-paddle swimmers with a rigid trunk.
  • Ichthyosauria 1 Dolphin-shaped, live-bearing, ringed vertebrae.

Synapsida & mammals 2

The line that led to us. The sail-backs are in here, not with the dinosaurs.

  • Sphenacodontidae 1 Permian predators with a neural-spine sail.
  • Cetacea 0 Fully aquatic mammals with hind limbs reduced to vestiges.
  • Proboscidea 1 Elephants and their extinct kin; tusks are modified incisors.
  • Carnivora 0 Shearing carnassial teeth, four or five toes, no hooves.

Stem vertebrates 1

Jawed and jawless fish that carry the earliest bone in the record.

  • Placodermi 1 Arthrodire and antiarch head shields with a neck joint.

Invertebrates 3

Everything with an exoskeleton or no skeleton at all. Most of the fossil record by count.

  • Radiodonta 1 Stem arthropods with a ring of toothed grasping appendages.
  • Lobopodia 0 Soft-bodied panarthropods walking on stubby unjointed legs.
  • Trilobita 1 Calcite eyes, a three-lobed axis, and moult halves everywhere.
  • Insecta 1 Six legs, two wing pairs, tracheal respiration.
中文

Cambrian 539 to 485 Ma

Olenoides

油栉虫属

A middle Cambrian trilobite, and one of the few known in three dimensions with its legs, antennae and gut intact. From the Burgess Shale, where mudflows buried a living seafloor community in fine-grained mud.

Published Reading time 2 min read

Olenoides — bone plate
Plate drawn from a per-clade shape library; scaled to published body length.

Why this trilobite is famous

Most trilobites are known from their dorsal shield alone, because that is the only mineralized part and the only part that survives ordinary fossilization. The Burgess Shale is not ordinary. Olenoides specimens from the Walcott and Marble Canyon quarries preserve the dorsal shield and, under it, the walking legs with their gill branches, the antennae in front, and a dark trace along the midline that is the gut.

  • Dorsal shield: three lobes, a raised central axis and two side lobes.
  • Legs: one pair per segment, each with an inner walking branch and an outer gill branch.
  • Antennae: a single long pair in front of the mouth.
  • Gut: a dark mid-line trace from mouth to pygidium.

Moulting, and why there are so many specimens

Trilobites grew by moulting, and the moulted exoskeleton comes apart along weak lines, with the free cheeks often separating from the cranidium. Many Burgess Shale slabs show accumulations of disarticulated shields, which are moults rather than dead animals. Distinguishing a moult assemblage from a death assemblage is one of the routine judgements in trilobite work.

The Burgess Shale, and how it was found

Charles Walcott discovered the main quarry in 1909 on Fossil Ridge in Yoho National Park, and worked it for years while he was Secretary of the Smithsonian. The Marble Canyon quarry, found in 2012 about 40 km to the southeast, produces a somewhat different community and helped show that the Burgess Shale is not one deposit but a set of them, separated in space and time.

Quarry Found Character
Walcott Quarry 1909 the classic Burgess assemblage
Raymond Quarry 1930 coarser, different preservation
Marble Canyon 2012 new taxa, dense Olenoides clusters

Three quarries, one formation, and no two giving the same animal list.

How it fed

The legs of Olenoides are grooved and the animal has no detectable jaws. The standard reading is a deposit feeder: legs churned the surface sediment, a food groove along the leg passed particles forward to the mouth, and the animal digested whatever organic matter came with them. Some specimens show the gut filled with mud.

Sources

Reference works and further reading for the material in this entry.

Where the argument is

Whether the Burgess Shale trilobites were tolerant of low oxygen. The Marble Canyon quarry has produced Olenoides in dense clusters along with evidence of mass mortality, and one reading is that these were animals killed by an oxygen-poor mudslide. A 2017 study of the distributions argued that trilobites in the Burgess Shale were not confined to well-oxygenated patches, which weakens the oxygen-tolerance argument.

Frequently misread

  • ClaimThe Burgess Shale preserves only hard parts, so soft-bodied animals there are not real.

    What the record showsThe Burgess Shale is a soft-tissue deposit: the animals were buried in fine mud by mudflows, and what is preserved is largely cuticle, gut traces and limbs. That is why Olenoides is known in three dimensions with legs and antennae -- the hard, mineralized part of the exoskeleton is only part of the fossil.

  • ClaimTrilobites died out before the dinosaurs appeared.

    What the record showsTrilobites appeared in the Cambrian and survived until the end-Permian extinction, 252 million years ago -- which is after the first dinosaurs had already appeared in the Triassic. They were extinct before the Jurassic, but not before the dinosaurs.

Same period, same cabinet Cambrian

  1. Anomalocaris 1 kg - 2 kg
  2. Meganeura 0 kg - 0 kg